The ubiquity of 1990s and early aughts nostalgia on Instagram, TikTok, and beyond has led, in recent years, to a resurgence of bodysuits, brown lipstick, combat boots, and chokers. But yearning for the semi-recent past has also reminded those of us with short memories that the late, great Val Kilmer once romanced Cher; Liv Tyler once dated Joaquin Phoenix; and that before Ben, Jennifer Garner was wed to one Scott Foley. Please join us as we dive down this frankly thrilling rabbit hole and rehash the celebrity couples you forgot about—or just never knew existed.